The X-Files

Sunday Mornings with Mulder and Scully – Unusual Suspects

While David Duchovny was preparing to film the episode The Unnatural (last week’s blog and the episode that aired before today’s episode) the showrunners decided to do a sequel to season five episode Unusual Suspects. For a refresher, it was the flashback episode where Mulder met the Lone Gunmen while chasing a lead and Susanne Modeski was kidnapped by men in a van at the end of the episode. That episode didn’t feature Scully because Gillian Anderson was filming a movie at the time, so it seemed only fair that Scully get her won episode with America’s favorite paranoid side characters.

The Lone Gunmen, Byers, Langly, and Frohike, find themselves in Las Vegas at a conference. Byers, who had essentially fallen in love with Susanne Modeski in the previous episode, begins the proceedings with a fantasy sequence about his happy marriage and family life with Modeski. This never happened, of course, but a guy can hope. He sees Modeski at the casino they are staying in and gets the other two to investigate.

Problem is, they need help. They use computer software to replicate Mulder’s voice and convince Scully to fly to Vegas in the middle of the night to help them. It turns out that Modeski is married and a whole lot of convoluted plot points later, Scully ends up drugged in a series of mildly funny events where she giddily accepts drinks and cigarettes from a group of men. Eventually, they realize she was drugged and decide to use the drug later to free Modeski from what turns out to be a pretty bad situation.

At the end of the episode, when Scully finally gets ahold of Mulder to ask where his is, she realizes she has been duped. And she just states, “I’m going to kick their asses.” A joke that comes full circle because Frohike was sure that that is exactly what she would do when she realized what really happened.

Honestly, while I love the nonsense that transpires in this episode and the hilarity of seeing Scully in such a different light, I also see this as a throw away episode. Filler to even out the season’s 22 episodes. I love that it exists, but it has no bearing on the mythology whatsoever and, let’s be honest, there is no real way for Scully to trust them after this. She never brings it up again when she sees them, which I find odd. So yeah, total throw away. A great piece of pointless episode that really only serves to get us one year closer to the spinoff that aired during season eight. The spinoff wouldn’t air until March 4, 2001, almost two full years after this episode that aired on May 2, 1999.

Bryan Spicer directed this episode. He has a prolific career directing television that includes Castle, 24, House, Heroes, CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, Hawaii Five-O, and Magnum P.I. The was the only episode of The X-Files that he directed, but he did go on to direct six of the episode of the short lived The Lone Gunmen series. Many of those episode have the same feel as this one which might explain why it only lasted one season. Unfortunately, the show had just hit its stride when it was cancelled. Much like Millennium, Carter used The X Files to give The Lone Gunmen a proper finale in season nine. I’m looking forward to discussing it since it’ll be one of the few high points of that season.

Until next week, the truth is out there. And so is Susanne Modeski because she didn’t end up staying with Byers.


Discover more from Becky Tyler Art and Photography

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.