Book Review Books

Book Review – The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett

Sometimes, a book can be both great and too depressingly serious. The Four Winds by Kristen Hannah comes to mind. Thoughtful and well written with an interesting story, but not something I’ll ever want to experience reading again. The Calamity Club will likely fall into that category for me. It doesn’t have the humor that her previous book The Help did, but it does have a group of women discovering who they are so in that way, I did like it.

This book is told from three perspectives. First, Meg is an orphan who is told her mother abandoned her when she disappeared suddenly. Second, her mother, Chris, did not abandon her but was put in a mental institution for speaking to a black man at a train station. The woman who put her there also works at the orphanage Meg ends up at and the reason why is simple. Female bitterness that her husband had an affair with Chris and they had a baby. The third perspective is that of Birdie, a spinster who travels to see her sister in Oxford, Mississippi to ask for borrowed money. Her sister Frances works at said orphanage, and her marriage is not what it seems. Her husband is very much gay but married her anyway to keep that fact a secret. And he has lost his job at a bank leaving his mother and wife penniless and about to lose their family estate.

What on Earth do desperate women do in 1933 Mississippi when the Great Depression slogs on and money is scarce? Well, you sell the one thing that men will always want and need. When Chris is released from the mental institution and shows up looking for Meg mere days after Meg is legally adopted, Chris forms a friendship with Birdie who ends up drawn into a plan to open a whorehouse. Yes, that’s right. One run by women. Their rules. Their terms. And only long enough to earn enough money for Chris to get Meg back and to pay off the past due mortgage on both Frances’s home and on the one Birdie left her own mother in to visit Frances. Even coming up with a name for this venture was difficult for them and they even floated the name Calamity Club which is where the book gets its title.

Sound easy. Sure. Except that Garrett Pitman, the woman who runs the orphanage, is campaigning to have anything deemed morally corrupt to be even more against the law in prohibition era Mississippi and one of the women living in the whorehouse is actually black though she doesn’t look it. Living with or having sex with a black woman was strictly forbidden and all the worries Birdie has over it soon become worse when Frances and her mother in law come home early from a trip Birdie sent them on.

This book is one bad thing after another. One battle after another. Meg, Birdie, and Chris have to fight for every little thing in life. Meg, finally adopted by rich people, is forced to lie about their alcoholism to stay with them. Birdie does everything in her power to save Frances’ home while Frances treats her with disdain and judgement. And Chris just wants her kid back and has to risk getting thrown back in the asylum to do it. Bad, bad, and more bad. Was depressing to read for quite a while and the happy ending is only so because mother and daughter are reunited. The “what now?” still lingers on as the book ends.

The women forge strong bonds and find strength within themselves they didn’t know they had. For the most part, it all works out – at least as well as it could during that time period. What really gave me a more positive take on this book was finding out that it was Kathryn Stockett’s point to bring attention to how bad women, gays, and black people were treated. I mean, we all know they were. But, her point was to give us deeper understanding on how certain medical practices from that era were exploited by men to keep control over women and minorities and were later explored by Hitler, and we all know how that turned out. In today’s society, with the rise of extreme conservatism that many associate with the Hitler regime, finding out that Stockett’s intent was to draw parallels to what is going on today endeared this book to me a bit more. Granted, I’m never reading all this bad again. But I’m glad I gave it a read. Gave me a lot to think about and I think it will do the same for you.

4 out of 5 stars.


Discover more from Becky Tyler Art and Photography

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.